Discussion
The primary PROTYS study looked at patients with RRMS treated with natalizumab for 1 year and aimed to assess correlations between changes in disability status and HRQoL; the post hoc analysis looked further at factors that may influence QoL in patients with MS treated with natalizumab.
While there was no statistically significant difference in global HRQoL change (MusiQoL index score) between ‘EDSS improved’ and ‘EDSS stable’ groups of patients, natalizumab treatment did appear to improve several domains of HRQoL: fatigue, symptoms, overall health state, sexual dysfunction and work productivity, regardless of whether EDSS scores were stable or improved. Additional results and discussion regarding fatigue and work productivity are characterised in online supplemental information.
With respect to changes in EDSS within 1 year of natalizumab treatment, the majority (80.0%) of patients had stable EDSS scores, with all other patients (except for one with EDSS progression) showing sustained EDSS improvement. Long-term data from the 10 year real-world Tysabri Observational Programme (TOP) study revealed a 10-year cumulative probability of disability improvement of 33.1% and of worsening 27.8%.16 Furthermore, in the TOP study which provides the real-world experience of 5384 patients, 23.9% (n=1287) had confirmed disability improvement.17 In the PROTYS study, after 1 year of treatment with natalizumab 17.1% (6/35) of patients were assessed as ‘EDSS improved,’ 80% (28/35) of patients were ‘EDSS stable’ and 2.9% (1/35) of patients were ‘EDSS worsened’. These differing results may be due to the low study participant number in the PROTYS study (n=35), the different periods of analysis for EDSS (sustained for ≥12 week for PROTYS and sustained for ≥24 weeks for TOP), and differences in patient demographics (for PROTYS the median EDSS was 3.00 with a range of 1.00–5.50).17
Concerning changes in global HRQoL, we report a slight improvement in global HRQoL as measured by the MusiQoL index score. Planche et al reported a statistically significant improvement in MusiQoL in a population of patients with RRMS treated with natalizumab (n=48).28 Therein, the mean MusiQoL score increased from 58.6 at baseline to 68.1 at 1 year (p<0.001).28 The increase in MusiQoL score was significant at 6 months after baseline and remained significant but did not increase beyond a score of 69.8 over 3 years.28 It is difficult to make direct comparisons between the PROTYS study and the study of Planche et al because our analysis was restricted to comparisons between ‘EDSS improved’ and ‘EDSS stable’ groups of patients. Interestingly, mean HRQoL at baseline was higher in the PROTYS study compared with the study by Planche et al,28 and the mean MusiQoL scores in both populations of patients in both studies were approximately 70 after 1 year of natalizumab treatment. Improvements in HRQoL with natalizumab treatment have also been reported by others using evaluations other than MusiQoL.3 10 In Planche et al the HRQoL significantly improved within 6 months of treatment with natalizumab and this was sustained through 3 years of treatment.28 It is therefore conceivable that we did not detect a statistically significant difference due to the small number of patients in each EDSS group, and the comparison being restricted to ‘EDSS stable’ and ‘EDSS improved’ groups of patients.
In the post hoc analysis, it was shown that improvements observed in MusiQoL global index after 1 year of natalizumab treatment correlated with improvements in the ability to cope with symptoms, in overall health, in primary causes of sexual dysfunction (MSISQ-19) and in presenteeism (WPAI). This suggests that improvements in patient psychological well-being, resolution of MS symptoms including fatigue and sexual dysfunction, and increases in workability may be important factors contributing to the increases in overall QoL.
Our results aligned with those of Planche et al, who reported that improvements in MusiQoL were mainly driven by the subparameters ‘symptoms’, ‘activity of daily living’, ‘psychological well-being’ and ‘coping’.28 The improvements in overall QoL over 1 year for patients initiating natalizumab in the PROTYS study are consistent with prior reports of natalizumab treatment effects on QoL.3
In a recent study—also on Swiss patients with MS—use of the EuroQol 5 Dimension (EQ-5D) and EQ-VAS showed that fatigue, depression and spasticity were important contributors to disease burden at a population level. For RRMS, the EQ-VAS was mostly impacted by balance problems, depression, dizziness and spasticity.6 Although in the PROTYS study the ‘EDSS improved’ group had significantly greater improvements in EQ-VAS compared with the ‘EDSS stable’ group (mean change=14.5 vs −0.1, p=0.011), the post hoc analysis revealed no correlation between change of MusiQoL global index and changes of EQ-5D. Others have reported significant correlations between high EDSS scores and lower EQ-5D index scores.29
Even though in the PROTYS study significant correlations between MusiQoL global index and changes in EQ-5D were not found, the mean change of the ‘EDSS improved’ group may be clinically meaningful. A study by Kohn et al found the minimal clinical important difference (MCID) for the EQ-5D index scores to range from 0.050 to 0.084 with patients with severe disability having higher MCIDs than patients with mild-moderate disability.30 However, the study is limited in this aspect by the fact that these MIDs were not considered during study design, and thus this is an area where future research would be useful.
As regards sexual dysfunction, it has been shown that tertiary sexual dysfunction increases as HRQoL decreases.31 We found that the MSISQ-19 subparameter ‘tertiary’ was significantly more improved in the ‘EDSS improved’ group compared with the ‘EDSS stable’ group (mean change=-3.5 vs −0.1, p=0.029. Furthermore, the post hoc analysis showed that improvements in sexual life were correlated with the improvement of the MusiQoL global index. This was consistent with the findings in the ‘MusiQoL improved’ patients showing that improvement in MusiQoL global index correlated with the score of the MSISQ-19 for primary causes of sexual dysfunction. In addition, a negative association between the increase in ‘tertiary causes of sexual dysfunction’ score and the improvement of the MusiQoL global index was found (online supplemental tables 3,4). Significant improvements in sexual dysfunction (based on MSISQ-19) within 24 weeks of starting natalizumab treatment have also been shown in another study.32 Given that mental health aspects of HRQoL have been shown to be detrimentally impacted by sexual dysfunction,33 and that our results suggest that resolution of MS symptoms such as sexual dysfunction may be an important factor contributing to the increases in overall QoL, aspects of sexual dysfunction in patients with RRMS treated with natalizumab should be further investigated in larger studies.
This study had several limitations; slow recruitment, which led to small numbers of patients and meant that the original recruitment goals were not met, risk stratification strategies that precluded treatment with natalizumab in patients positive for JCV antibodies, and some sites reported low number of patients having disease activity enough to fulfil natalizumab indications according to the local prescribing information. This may have been affected by new MS therapies, fingolimod, alemtuzumab, teriflunomide and dimethyl fumarate, which were entering the market prior to or at the time of recruitment. The study duration was also limited to 1 year, which may have been too short to observe significant changes in some of the domains of HRQoL. Finally, the EDSS was limited to fully ambulatory patients (EDSS up to 3.5) and therefore we cannot assess impact of higher degrees of disability on HRQoL.